Choosing between double pane and triple pane windows is one of the biggest decisions you’ll make during window replacement. Both options are major upgrades from single pane windows, but they have important differences.
At Utah Window Experts, we help homeowners make this choice every day. The right answer depends on your specific situation, budget, and goals. We’ve installed thousands of both types and learned what works best in different scenarios.
Here’s everything you need to know to make the right choice for your home.
Table of Contents
What’s the Difference?
The difference is exactly what it sounds like. Double pane windows have two pieces of glass with one sealed space between them. Triple pane windows have three pieces of glass with two sealed spaces.
Both types fill the spaces between glass with insulating gas, usually argon or krypton. This gas provides better insulation than regular air. The spaces are sealed around the edges to keep the gas in and moisture out.
Triple pane windows are thicker and heavier than double pane windows. They typically measure about 1.5 inches thick compared to 1 inch for double pane. This extra thickness affects installation and frame requirements.
The additional glass layer and air space in triple pane windows provide extra insulation. They also add weight, cost, and complexity to the window design.
Energy Efficiency Comparison
Energy efficiency is where you see the biggest difference between these two options.
Double pane windows typically have U-values between 0.25 and 0.35. U-value measures heat transfer – lower numbers mean better insulation. This represents a huge improvement over single pane windows, which have U-values around 1.0.
Triple pane windows perform even better, with U-values typically between 0.15 and 0.25. That’s about 20-30% better insulation than comparable double pane windows.
In real terms, this means triple pane windows can reduce your heating and cooling costs by an additional 10-15% compared to double pane windows. The exact savings depend on your home’s size, insulation, and heating/cooling system.
However, there’s a point of diminishing returns. The jump from single to double pane saves much more energy than the jump from double to triple pane.
Cost Difference Breakdown
Triple pane windows cost significantly more than double pane windows. Here’s what you can expect in Utah:
Double pane windows typically cost $400-600 per window for quality units with professional installation. This includes standard low-E coatings and argon gas fills.
Triple pane windows typically cost $600-900 per window for comparable quality and installation. That’s about 40-50% more than double pane windows.
The price gap comes from several factors. Triple pane windows use more materials – an extra piece of glass, more gas, and stronger frames to support the extra weight. Manufacturing is also more complex.
Installation costs are usually similar, but triple pane windows sometimes require frame modifications due to their extra thickness and weight.
For a typical home replacing 15 windows, you’re looking at about $3,000-4,500 extra to go with triple pane instead of double pane windows.
Best Climates for Each
Climate plays a huge role in determining which option makes more sense.
Double pane windows work excellently in moderate climates and most areas where winters aren’t extremely harsh. They provide great energy savings compared to single pane windows without the extra cost of triple pane.
Triple pane windows shine in climates with extreme temperatures. They’re most popular in northern states like Minnesota, Wisconsin, and northern Maine where winters are brutally cold.
Utah sits in an interesting middle ground. Many areas have winters that can be quite cold, especially in northern regions and higher elevations. But they’re not as extreme as the upper Midwest. Summers are hot but not as consistently brutal as desert climates.
This means both options can work well in many climates, depending on your specific location and priorities.
Sound Insulation Test
Beyond energy efficiency, windows also affect how much outside noise gets into your home.
Double pane windows provide good sound reduction compared to single pane windows. The air space between glass panes helps block sound waves. Most double pane windows reduce outside noise by about 20-25 decibels.
Triple pane windows perform even better for sound control. The extra glass layer and air space can reduce outside noise by 30-35 decibels. This is a noticeable difference, especially if you live near busy roads, airports, or other noise sources.
However, sound reduction also depends on glass thickness and spacing between panes. Some premium double pane windows with different glass thicknesses can match or beat basic triple pane windows for sound control.
If noise reduction is your main concern, focus on windows specifically designed for sound control rather than just choosing triple pane automatically.
Installation Considerations
Installing triple pane windows requires more planning than double pane windows.
The extra weight of triple pane windows means your window frames need to be strong enough to support them. Older homes sometimes need frame reinforcement or replacement to handle the additional weight properly.
Triple pane windows are also thicker, which can create problems with window sills, trim, and interior/exterior aesthetics. Your installer needs to plan for these issues during measurement and ordering.
Installation time is usually similar for both types. However, triple pane windows require more careful handling due to their weight. This sometimes means more installers or special equipment.
Make sure your installation company has experience with triple pane windows. Improper installation can cause problems with operation and void your warranty.
ROI & Payback Period
Return on investment is crucial when deciding between double and triple pane windows.
Double pane windows typically pay for themselves through energy savings in 8-12 years in most climates. This assumes you’re replacing single pane windows and factoring in both heating and cooling savings.
Triple pane windows take longer to pay back the additional cost. The extra $3,000-4,500 investment might save you an additional $200-300 per year in energy costs. This means a payback period of 12-20 years just for the upgrade from double to triple pane.
However, payback calculations don’t include other benefits like improved comfort, noise reduction, and increased home value. These factors might justify the extra cost even if pure energy savings don’t.
Also consider how long you plan to stay in your home. If you’re planning to move within 10 years, the energy savings alone might not justify triple pane windows.
Which Option Is Right for You?
Based on our experience, here are our recommendations for different situations and climates.
Choose double pane windows if you live in moderate climates with mild to moderate winters. These areas get cold enough to benefit from good insulation but aren’t extreme enough to justify the extra cost of triple pane windows.
Consider triple pane windows if you live in harsh climates with very cold winters or extreme temperature swings. Areas with consistently cold weather, high elevation, or severe weather conditions can benefit more from the extra insulation.
Also consider triple pane windows if your home faces challenging conditions. Houses exposed to constant wind, extreme sun exposure, or significant noise sources might benefit from the additional protection.
Your home’s other energy features matter too. If you have excellent insulation and an efficient HVAC system, the benefits of triple pane windows are smaller. If your home has poor insulation, focus on that first before upgrading to triple pane windows.
Our Top Picks for 2025
Based on our experience and customer feedback, here are our current top recommendations.
For double pane windows, we recommend models with low-E coatings and argon gas fills as standard features. Look for U-values of 0.30 or lower and SHGC (Solar Heat Gain Coefficient) ratings appropriate for Utah’s climate.
Quality brands we frequently install include Andersen, Pella, and Milgard. These manufacturers offer good warranties and have local service support.
For triple pane windows, focus on models specifically designed for energy efficiency rather than just adding a third pane to existing designs. The best triple pane windows use krypton gas and advanced low-E coatings.
Avoid the cheapest options in either category. Poor quality windows won’t deliver the performance or longevity you expect, regardless of how many panes they have.
Making Your Decision
The choice between double and triple pane windows depends on your specific situation, priorities, and budget.
Choose double pane windows if you want excellent energy efficiency at a reasonable cost. They’re perfect for most Utah homes and offer great value for money.
Choose triple pane windows if maximum energy efficiency is your priority and you can justify the extra cost. They make most sense in extreme climates, very noisy locations, or homes where you plan to stay long-term.
Don’t forget to consider the total window package. Frame material, hardware quality, and installation matter just as much as the number of glass panes.
Get Expert Advice
Every home is different, and the best choice depends on your specific situation. At Utah Window Experts, we help you evaluate all the factors that matter for your home.
Our window evaluation process includes energy analysis, cost-benefit calculations, and recommendations based on your home’s specific needs and your budget.
Ready to explore your options? Use our Window Project Builder to think through your priorities, or contact us for a free consultation.
We’ll help you choose the right windows for your home – whether that’s double pane, triple pane, or something in between.
